Adaptive Heuristics in Stock Selection
Working Paper
In one sentence
We interview investors to learn directly how they choose stocks, document the rules they use, and evaluate their historical effectiveness; our analysis suggests that investors use rules that are well suited to their priorities and local market conditions.
Summary
We conduct AI-led, open-ended interviews with 1,540 investors across ten countries to understand how they decide which individual stocks to purchase. We identify thirteen heuristics that capture the reasoning of 95.2% of investors in our sample. Investors are more likely to choose heuristics they perceive as more effective for the goals they prioritize, and these perceptions align with historical performance. Stocks associated with chosen heuristics outperform those associated with unused heuristics on prioritized goals but underperform on goals investors do not prioritize. These findings suggest that investors’ reliance on simple rules is partly adaptive: they tend to choose rules suited to their priorities and local market conditions.
Data, code & appendices
Please click here for the Online Appendix.