Working Paper2026

Not Yet or Never? Deliberation State and the Reasons for Nonparticipation

Working Paper

In one sentence

We argue that studies can reach opposing conclusions regarding the leading explanations why people do not partake in certain activities (e.g., childbearing) simply because their samples contain different shares of people who have permanently ruled out the activity and people who remain open to it.

Summary

This paper studies a general problem in research on nonparticipation: surveys and interviews often pool people who have permanently ruled out an activity with those who have not participated but remain open to doing so. We call this distinction deliberation state and argue that the reasons people give differ systematically across these groups. We examine this idea using AI-led, open-ended interviews with 1,074 childless adults in Singapore, South Korea, and the United States. Lifestyle autonomy outweighs economic security among those who have ruled out parenthood (60.2 versus 35.1 percent), while economic security dominates among those who remain open to it (50.2 versus 10.8 percent). These differences persist across demographic subgroups and alternative classifications. The findings illustrate how studies of nonparticipation, including studies of investing, working, starting a business, or having children, can reach opposing conclusions regarding the leading explanation for non-participation simply because their samples differ in deliberation-state composition.

Data, code & appendices

Please click here for the Online Appendix.

Research topics

nonparticipationdeliberation statefertilitysurvey measurementAI-led interviews